Bloom Into You (and Me), a Story About How Representation is Important

Bloom Into You (11)

I talk a lot about how “representation in fiction is important”—it’s kind of the backbone of most of my writing, from my blog posts to my PhD, where it factors into both the creative element and the theoretical part behind it. It didn’t start out as a project about LGBTQIA+ rep, necessarily, but through everything I’ve done it’s leaned more and more in that direction, as a result of me following tangents I’m interested in and passionate about.

Early last year, my supervisor asked me why exactly this area was so important to me, trying to get to the heart of the matter. I think she asked me this for her benefit and mine—after all, you want to understand what makes your own project tick, and have a grip on exactly what your priorities are and why they are your priorities. The answer I ended up coming up with was a personal one that sort of surprised even me: I sidestepped the traditional “everyone deserves to see themselves represented in the media they consume” and instead said something like “queer rep is important to me because I think, had I seen more of it, my life might have gone quite differently.”

Oof! Wow! That’s baring my soul a little, hey? Let’s shrink back behind the comfortable shield of media analysis for a bit, and talk about Bloom Into You.

The series’ first episode opens with its protagonist, high schooler Yuu, musing about romance. She’s listened to hundreds of love songs and read stacks of shoujo manga, popular media filling her with a certain set of expectations of What Exactly Love Is. Yuu knows her stuff, guys. She’s put the evidence together from a wide pool, and she knows what love will look and feel like—the only thing left to do is wait for that feeling to happen to her. So when a classmate asks her out, and she doesn’t feel like she’s floating off the earth, she is gutted. Every piece of media she’s ever been exposed to told her love is a particular experience, and when she doesn’t have that experience, she feels like she’s done something fundamentally wrong.

Subtitles: "But no matter what, I can't reach it..."

With her sparkly, blossom-filled love confession scene gone off-script, Yuu comes to the conclusion that she simply can’t fall in love. With this in her heart, she feels deeply alienated from the world around her and from her peers. Her friends gush about boys they have crushes on or what their “type” is, and Yuu hovers awkwardly on the edge of the conversation. She listens to those mushy love songs she loved so much before, and feels like they’re speaking a different language. On the flipside, however, she’s elated when she meets Touko, a girl who’s reportedly turned down every romantic confession she’s ever received. With her, Yuu feels a little less alone in the world, and is able to admit aloud to her complicated relationship with love. At this, Touko gives her a reassuring pat on the head and says: “It’s rough when you think that you have to love someone, huh?”

I’ll be honest with you, dear reader: there were so many parts of this episode that spoke to me, but that sweet, sympathetic little line from Touko absolutely hit me in the gut. Of course, Touko soon spoils this supportive moment somewhat by blurting “I think I’m falling in love with you!” at the very end of the episode, thus kicking off the weird and complicated relationship between the two girls and their own messy feelings that drives the series. But hey, it’s important to remember that Bloom Into You is not a love story so much as a story about love, and, principally, about the different crooked shapes that love can take—shapes you don’t often see in those sparkly fictional stories where Yuu has gotten all her information about romance from.

And that’s what’s at the heart of the matter here, encapsulated so brilliantly in that series premiere: Bloom Into You is a story about how fiction and popular media set up Very Particular Expectations about what love is, about how it ought to go, and how it impacts the self. And if you don’t see yourself reflected in any of those Very Particular Expectations—if you don’t experience romantic attraction, if you feel that attraction to the “wrong” people, if you don’t feel that Very Particular earth-shattering self-actualisation from dating someone—you have no real other choice but to wonder if you’re a glitch in the system.

Bloom Into You (17)

There’s been a lot of discussion about how it is very easy to read Yuu as aro-ace, a reading that I agree is very strong, despite how it might seem to contradict Yuu’s place as the protagonist in a romance. But the thread around Yuu’s declaration that she “can’t fall in love” works just as well, I think, for an aromantic and/or asexual narrative and for a lesbian narrative (and, indeed, sexuality is a complicated spectrum and there’s no reason Yuu can’t be a bit of both). I’m biromantic and asexual, which is kind of like wearing two layers of invisibility gear, but also means I can see where Yuu’s coming from twice over. Either way you slice it, this assumption of Yuu’s comes from her alienation by the media, which has always painted True Romance a Very Particular way.

If every piece of media you’ve ever interacted with tells you that Girls Fall In Love with Boys, and you don’t fall in love with boys, well, it’s perfectly reasonable to assume that maybe you don’t fall in love at all. If different experiences of love—be they different sexualities, different power dynamics, or hell, even different types of romantic storyline—aren’t presented to you for consideration, and aren’t presented as normal and viable, they might not ever cross your mind.

Interestingly, it’s not that Yuu doesn’t know queerness is A Thing. She knows that lesbian books exist, at least, as shown when Touko accidentally buys a steamy sapphic romance at Yuu’s family bookstore (Yuu recognises it and Touko doesn’t, leading to much embarrassment on the latter’s part). But of course, knowing it’s A Thing doesn’t immediately translate to considering it could be A Thing for you. Especially if—and I think this is the telling detail here—it’s presented as A Thing only in selective, fringe media rather than pop culture. That book is a heavy novel from a serious bookstore, after all, whereas Yuu mostly interacts with (and gets her idea of love from) girly comics and pop music. If it’s not normalised in the mainstream, it remains a non-mainstream, non-normative concept—something for other people, obviously, and not something that could ever apply to me, who is normal.

Subtitle: "I'm just a little slower than others when it comes to sprouting wings"

As many people do, I wandered through adolescence and early adulthood blithely presuming I was straight, simply because, well, I hadn’t really been presented with any other options. I was assigned female at birth and thus I liked boys, and would one day fall in love with a boy, sleep with that boy (because that’s what you do when you love someone), then, all going well, marry that boy and have 2.5 children. That was the narrative, conveyed in movies, TV shows, novels, magazines, and music, the overarching narrative of assumed heterosexuality that permeated every interaction I had with society at large, whether that was implicit and silent or more explicit, like the many times my friends told me “you have to like someone!” during those terrifying interrogation sessions that somehow always took place at sleepovers.

Touko’s gentle “It’s rough when you feel like you have to love someone, huh?” hit me like a brick. Because, though the terms might sound deceptively simple, yes! So many people go through their teens—and their life—assuming that they have to love someone, and that they have to love someone A Very Particular Way, because that is what they’ve been told over and over again. When I did eventually like someone, I assumed that romantic attraction and sexual attraction were one and the same, and that sex was something required for a healthy relationship, just something that you do, simply because no one told me otherwise. How different could things have gone, for me, if something like Let’s Talk About Love or Tash Hearts Tolstoy had come out ten years earlier and I’d read it when I was in high school? If I’d been told asexuality was a thing that existed, and I’d been given the space to wonder if maybe I might be ace? As it was, I figured it out several years deep in a sexual relationship, making it a realisation that came with a lot of heavy and messy emotions.

I don’t want to be overdramatic and say I’m so invested in seeing, and studying, queer representation in fiction because I’m mourning an alternate youth of mine. But… well, I just wonder sometimes. What if I’d seen Rosa Diaz come out as bisexual on TV when I was younger? What if all these brilliant YA novels about a whole spectrum of queer characters had been available when I was in their target demographic? What if there had been more Love, Simons and The Miseducation of Cameron Posts on at the movies when my high school friends and I had been hanging around the cinema? Or, hey, what if Bloom Into You had been one of the anime series we’d watched?

Bloom Into You (22)

Mostly, it makes me happy to see how far media representation has come in even just a decade or so, and gives me hope for the way it’s going—and, needless to say, makes me hopeful for everyone who will grow up potentially seeing themselves in the fiction around them, exposed to a wide range of perspectives and identities and given the chance to figure out where they fit in all that, rather than presuming anything about themselves and feeling weird and broken when A Set of Very Particular Expectations doesn’t quite sit right.

For all the ups and downs I’ve felt about Bloom Into You, it feels a very important piece of media—not just for its queer representation, but for what it says about queer representation within the text itself. And this isn’t even to dive into Yuu and Touko’s increasingly complicated feelings for one another that develop throughout the series, or the storyline about Sayaka’s middle school relationship that directly confronts tropes and social ideas like “just a phase”, or the even more aro-ace-coded character who views the relationships around him through the frame of “stories” that he’s fascinated by but has no desire to participate in.

There’s a lot going on in this series, and it has a lot to say about how love is often more complicated than fiction can lead us to assume. It’s messy, it’s confusing, it’s beautiful, it’s bizarre, and it can mean looking deep into your own soul and going “wait, what?”; all of which Bloom Into You captures with its various character arcs, Yuu’s at the heart of them all. In the end, she realises that she absolutely doesn’t fit into those Very Particular Expectations that her beloved media set out for her, but that’s okay. In fact, that’s more than okay, and she can defy those expectations and be happy. And that’s the message that I want my work to get across, too: as a message to my readership, but a message to my younger self as well.

Like this blog? Have you considered contributing to the tip jar?

15 Comments

Filed under Fun with Isms

15 responses to “Bloom Into You (and Me), a Story About How Representation is Important

  1. Abel

    I love that whole paragraph where you show you’re self-conscious about baring your soul and hide behind the “comfortable shield of media analysis.” It’s a mood. I also chuckled irl at the casual joke about having 2.5 children. I had kept rereading it out of awe of the wit required to make a point and a jab in the same breath.

    It was a fun read all the way through and made me appreciate the value this story has for others. I’m glad this was RT’ed onto my timeline!

  2. Very nice article that I thoroughly enjoyed to read, especially because some of it rings true for me (though is also a bit more complicated in the end). The whole piece about “if I’d seen more of it, my life might have gone rather differently” in particular, because that’s a thought I’ve been having ever since reading Hourou Musuko on my end, for example.

    As a pre-transition trans girl, to this day I’m not even sure whether I’m actually ace or not. Like, I know the way I am right now, I definitely am, but that’s more because of external circumstances (read: an absolute dislike of the body, so of course I’d never want something that just pushes what I dislike even more to the front), and who knows how it might look if I ever transition? That of course made that time of school all the more exhausting and frustrating though – knowing that you do like girls, but absolutely wanting to stay away from any relationship at all (now I know of course that it’s just because I didn’t want people to see me as a guy, but young me wasn’t that far at that point), and not really reciprocating love even after somebody confesses to you, heck, it actually feeling even a bit of a burden rather than something joyful. All while classmates kind of egged me on by asking stuff like why I still didn’t have a girlfriend, or them bragging about how they already one. Like, there was no ostracization or nasty rumors or anything, but still made me wonder whether something was fundamentally broken.

    If I’d know about stuff like ace, aro etc back then, that might have made my youth a bit easier to swallow, instead of wondering whether something’s actually broken on the inside. Admittedly, it might have warped my perception of myself a bit in the long run, because as mentioned above, to this day I’m still not really sure if it applies or not because right now it looks more like a conditional ace to me (if such a thing even exists), but yeah, Yuu’s struggles resonated with me quite a bit, which is why Bloom Into You (and Yuu in particular, too, although I like all of the cast) has a special place for me.

    But anyways, before I start to bore you or anything, really – thanks for writing that piece. It gave me yet another opportunity to collect my thoughts towards Bloom Into You even though my feelings regarding it are for the most part sorted out at this point (in a good way, of course, though I keep discovering even more nuances), and in general made for some good self-reflection too. I genuinely enjoyed the read!

    • I’m really glad this piece resonated with you, and thank you for taking the time to comment! The truth is that figuring yourself out can be a messy and confusing process, so I’m glad we can at least all have these spaces to share our experiences with it. For what it’s worth, I actually know a couple of trans people who went through a similar sort of process to what you’re talking about, identifying as ace until they began to transition–talking about it with them made me appreciate how fluid and complex things like gender and sexuality and hey, even just the concept of personal identity, are. If seeing yourself as being on the ace spectrum (and it is a spectrum–I would even say demisexual would count as “conditionally ace” if you’re looking for a word for it!) makes sense and seems to fit, then hey, you’re ace! And if that label no longer seems to fit as you grow and change and learn more about yourself, that’s totally cool too. One thing I’ve really embraced in my own journey of looking at my orientation going “????” is that it’s okay to not be completely sure, and it’s okay to accept it, and yourself, as a work in progress.

      Thanks again for sharing this personal story–I’m really happy that this article, and this series, is able to be a place where these discussions can happen and we can all find validation. Take care out there!

      • Honestly, no kidding. It’s a messy and confusing process, a tiresome one too. Takes a fair bit of courage too, because you’re essentially admitting to yourself that you’re not normal – at least not by the standards that society and your surroundings seem to set, even though that actually should be completely fine, there’s nothing wrong with that (though of course, reality’s a bit more complicated than that – at the very least I’m lucky to live in Central Europe, this would be even messier for those living in parts of the world like Eastern Europe or the Arabian countries). That one was one of my biggest hurdles as well before it finally clicked in my head, actually – just finding the courage to say, “Okay, maybe I’m different than most people in regards to this.”. And yeah, in the three to four years since I’ve had the realization, I did also realize that it’s okay how this is more or less a work in progress. I need time to figure everything out, and even then it’s not guaranteed that at least some finer nuances will stay the same. At the very least I know I’m not seeing myself as aro, because that side can work out easier – just need to find somebody who’d be willing to accept me as a girl/woman, so to speak.

        And of course, the same goes for you – take care out there as well!

  3. Pingback: Hey There, Demons: January ’19 Roundup | The Afictionado

  4. Pingback: Last Week in Geekdom – Your Weekly News Round-Up (1/28 – 2/3) | Bloom Reviews

  5. Pingback: [Links] 30 January - 5 February 2019: Five Years of #28DaysofBlackCosplay, Deputy PM Blames Women for Japan's Population Woes, and Ace Representation in Bloom Into You - ANIME FEMINIST

  6. Pingback: Okazu » Yuri Network News – (百合ネットワークニュース) – February 9, 2019

  7. Super

    Um, I don’t quite understand why you see here exactly the message about LGBT representation. Yuu is well aware of the existence of the qeer community and even has little doubt when thinking about her potential relationship with another girl.

    The show rather criticizes the oversupply of unrealistic idealized romance in the media in general, than qeer fiction in particular. Not to mention the fact that the value of this story is precisely in the fact that it never focuses on the sexuality of its characters, to put it bluntly, that qeer people are no different from straight. This is one of the reasons why this story resonates so well with people of any sexual or gender identity.

    At the same time, this can work in the case of Sayaka, whose experiences could be much easier and less traumatic if she initially met the happy role models of lesbian women and the positive acceptance of such a relationship.

  8. I am going through my email and finally reading this article which has been on my tbr pile for a few weeks. This whole thing rings so true to my experience as well. I sometimes wonder if romance would have ever come into my mind if it had not been so pervasive everywhere. You make a lot of good points and I am really interested in watching Bloom Into You cause it sounds like my jam.
    You always have really interesting discussions that I thoroughly enjoy reading. 😀

    • Thank you for saying so, and I’m really glad you like them! Bloom Into You is definitely a very interesting show (it has a lot of crossover appeal with queer YA, which you and I both know is The Good Stuff) that you should check out if you’re curious. It kept kicking me in the heart in really unexpected ways… and I mean that as praise 😛

  9. Pingback: Episode 70: The Spy Who Loved Me | Anime Brain Freeze

  10. Pingback: [Feature] Not “Just a Phase”: How Bloom Into You challenges common yuri tropes - ANIME FEMINIST

Leave a Reply to Annabelle Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s